I have not paddled a Night Heron, nor have had much experience in the OI...... ....so...I cannot comment upon performance.

However, I am building an OI and fit into one perfectly. I am 5' 10", 225 lbs. The OI fits beautifully, and has a surprising great initial stability. I wear size 12 shoes, and plan to raise a few forms about 1/2" for some extra room. Both boats are beauties to look at!

Also, check out a search for both boats in the archives...found them to be really helpful. If you haven't yet had the opportunity...paddle each one....the answer will come to you. I felt like I 'had arrived' when I paddled the OI.

Good luck...am sure you cannot go wrong with either boat.

Bob

: I'd be pleased to hear comments about the fit and paddling characteristics of
: the Night Heron ... especially if you're a big guy. I'm 6'2" ... 225#
: ... size 10-1/2 shoes and I can still slip into a 16 inch cockpit. I've
: narrowed down my choices to the Night Heron or Outer Island ... well ...
: at least before I change my mind again! My passion is performing sculling
: high braces (side sculling) ...

: Ken B.