Boat Building Forum

Find advice on all aspects of building your own kayak, canoe or any lightweight boats

Re: You be the judge
By:Ross Sieber
Date: 4/16/2001, 4:29 pm
In Response To: Re: You be the judge (E-bif)

: The budget was too small.

: The engineering was insufficient - the mast bearings failed, the hulls
: buckled.

: The construction was insufficient - the facings did not bond to the cores.

: The testing was insufficient - the construction problem was not detected.

: About par for the course for novel projects.

If true, that follows a classic model.
Engineering should be validated before construction.
Construction should be validated before testing.

I'm a software guy, but have seen this pattern more often than I would care to.
No checks and balances, and the project goes off the rails before having
any chance of succeeding.

I was actually told one time that there was no money in the budget for
design, and we had to go straight to construction. Yikes.
That project was less than a resounding success.

I don't know if that's what happened here, but I wouldn't be surprised.
This lesson isn't often learned until there is a catastrophic failure.

Messages In This Thread

You be the judge *Pic*
Pete Rudie -- 4/15/2001, 9:34 pm
Re: You be the jury
Geo. Cushing -- 4/17/2001, 2:42 pm
Re: You be the judge
E-bif -- 4/16/2001, 4:00 pm
Re: You be the judge
Ross Sieber -- 4/16/2001, 4:29 pm
Re: You be the judge
Shawn Baker -- 4/16/2001, 2:03 pm
Re: You be the judge
James Neely -- 4/16/2001, 8:57 am