Boat Building Forum

Find advice on all aspects of building your own kayak, canoe or any lightweight boats

Re: Kayakcraft review on Amazon.com
By:T. Howard
Date: 11/5/1999, 1:07 pm
In Response To: Kayakcraft review on Amazon.com (Tammy Hanks)

> I just couldn't resist jumping in here. I've heard some of you have read
> Kayakcraft and thought it was great. Well, go ahead and make your views
> known on Amazon.com. I just took a look and George is at it again and so
> far he's been the only one to review the book there. I think a balanced
> perspective is in order.

> Thanks and happy building.

> Tammy Hanks

Lets not forget his 1-star reviews of Nick Schade's book, as well as "Illustrated Guide to Wood Strip Canoe Building" by Susan Van Leuven. There's several other books out there as well that he hasn't "reviewed" yet. You have forgotten to slam "Building a Jawbone Kayak", "The Aleutian Kayak", "Baidarka: The Kayak", and a slew of others. Can hardly wait for those reviews. But seriously, can you really ask Ted Moores, Nick or others to provide all the information needed to build a boat that is "strong enough for your purpose"? How do they know the particular paddling conditions every reader will use their boat in? Isn't this assuming that the author knows every reader personally? The only person who could write a book with that knowledge is George himself, since he'd be the only one who'd read it. He's just full of himself enough to know himself very well indeed.

Next time I go to buy a commercially built boat, I'll be sure to ask the folks at Prijon, Perception, etc. if they've adequately tested their design and materials for my purposes. After they get done laughing at me, maybe I'll still buy the boat.

Messages In This Thread

Kayakcraft review on Amazon.com
Tammy Hanks -- 11/4/1999, 11:05 pm
Re: Kayakcraft review on Amazon.com
Jake Jacobson -- 11/5/1999, 11:47 pm
Re: Kayakcraft offset measurements
Paul G. Jacobson -- 11/6/1999, 12:30 am
Re: Kayakcraft offset measurements
Mike Scarborough -- 11/6/1999, 11:05 am
Re: Kayakcraft review on Amazon.com
Alan Resinger -- 11/5/1999, 8:38 pm
Re: Kayakcraft review on Amazon.com
T. Howard -- 11/5/1999, 1:07 pm
Re: Kayakcraft review on Amazon.com
Stan Woronko -- 11/5/1999, 10:58 am
Re: Kayakcraft review on Amazon.com
Mike Plumer -- 11/5/1999, 10:26 am
Re: Kayakcraft review on Amazon.com
lee -- 11/5/1999, 12:07 pm
Re: uh oh,in ones own backyard, again
lee -- 11/5/1999, 1:19 am