> This discussion is probably better suited for the Techniques BBS

> http://www.guillemot-kayaks.com/cgi-bin/Techniquesbbs.cgi But for now:

> Most of the things Tim says on his page about the paddle float could
> easily be said about his sponsons and the only person who would dispute it
> is Tim.

For the uninformed Nick is probably referring to the "discussion" which occurred in rec.boats.paddling when Tim was advocating the use of his sponsons there. I joined that group a short time after the incident occurred so I didn't get to witness it myself but people are still making references to it to this day.

> That said, sponsons are another tool to assist in your safety. They are
> not a cure-all, but in certain situations they are a useful tool.

> In the end, your safety on the water is more dependant on your own
> judgement than any gadget. If you paddle within your limits, you will
> probably never need your PFD, let alone some other self-rescue technique.
> Since I recommend wearing a PFD, I don't have anything against any other
> safety device used correctly, just don't let any device give you a false
> sense of security.

Nick also does not mention making the judgement of not going out under difficult conditions alone.

The first day I was ever in a sea kayak was during a class that I took and we were taught several rescue techniques including the use of a paddlefloat. Since then I've practiced a paddlefloat reentry many times. Once you've learned just how to do it properly it isn't that difficult but like any safety device practicing using it under controlled controlled conditions is a really good idea before relying on it under difficult conditions. I also learned how to roll my sea kayak last summer and practice under controlled conditions as often as possible so that when I need it should I unintentionally capsize, it will be there. The same kind of practice should be used when testing whether your paddling clothing is really going to keep you warm. Although I don't yet own one I've been told that if you purchase a dry suit it's a good idea to jump in cold water and see if it will really keep you dry before trusting that it will perform out on open water.